Doing the right thing….

One of the phrases from the government child poverty strategy that always sticks in my mind is around people who ‘do the right thing’. It is used to highlight how the welfare reforms and the ‘new approach’ to tackling child poverty will ‘reward’ these people. Below are the uses of the phrase in the strategy:

First, we must ensure that families can work themselves out of poverty – if they do the right thing we will make sure the system makes work pay.

The Universal Credit will support those who do the right thing, who take a full time job, to have an income which lifts them out of poverty.

… so that we create a system which rewards people who do the right thing and work themselves out of poverty

In the strategy, this approach is contrasted with the previous government’s approach which is characterised as being about attempting ‘to hit child poverty targets by paying out record amounts in welfare payments’ and an over-reliance on ‘simply throwing money at the symptoms’.

I recently came across a special issue of Local Economy from 1994 which explored ‘local anti-poverty initiatives’ and, from initial readings, a lot of the material is still very relevant today. This morning I read one of the articles, by Peter Alcock, called ‘Welfare rights and wrongs’ which examined the limits of local anti-poverty strategies and a couple of paragraphs seemed especially relevant to the ‘doing the right thing’ approach. Writing about poverty responses in times of economic recession and increasing poverty, he notes that:

At such times the problem of poverty becomes both morally more pressing and politically less containable. But recession also means that the expansive, and expensive, responses of better times are no longer available; and support from the state to the poor, the protection offered by employment and social security, is displaced by more limited support to working with poor people to seek their own solutions – an emphasis instead on from the poor to the state.

The shift in emphasis to working with, rather than for the poor, for all its success in promoting bottom-up community development and generating innovative and effective welfare rights activity, does mask the broader policy failure of economic development and social services in preventing the continuation, and the growth, of poverty in affluent welfare capitalist countries. What is more, despite the superficial attractions of the community base, in returning the problem of poverty to the poor people, it also risks a more sinister development — the pathologisation of poverty as the “problem of the poor”.

Nearly twenty years on from the publication of this article – amidst predictions of increased poverty in the coming years and the lack of evidence which supports the idea that this might be because more people are doing the ‘wrong things’ or, at the very least, not doing the ‘right things’, one could be forgiven for asking if our government was ‘doing the right thing’ by people who are living in poverty…


One response to “Doing the right thing….

  • Annette de Grandis

    The reality (which cannot be admitted by Governments) is that free market capitalism needs recessions, it is essentially cyclical in nature – that means that individuals have to be portrayed as the authors of their own misfortune – not ‘doing the right thing’ or ‘having the right skills’ or belonging to a ‘work shy underclass’ rather than as victims of an inherently unfair and unsaleable system. Policy and policy makers will never be able to tackle the real issues of poverty until they acknowledge this but this would cause such acute cognitive dissonance that real change through policy initiatives is impossible. Hence Peter Alcock’s comment is as relevant today as it was in 1994 and we are likely to see an increasing pathology of poverty and an increasing division into deserving and undeserving recipients of support

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: